Grill, Interrupted: Cape Cod Cafe Cheese Pizza (Ep 88)
Pizza Month rolls on, and the Bros hit the road to Cape Cod. Except they don’t, because Cape Cod Cafe isn’t on Cape Cod. It’s in Brockton, Massachusetts, where a roadside stop turned a 10-inch pan into a South Shore tradition. This week: Cape Cod Cafe Cheese Pizza.
The story: Cape Cod Cafe opened in 1939 in a former funeral home (ghost stories included) on the road to the Cape. In 1947, a newly returned WWII veteran named E. James “Papa” Jamoulis bought it and added pizza to the menu. Three generations later, the family still runs it and claims to have invented bar pizza. The frozen pies hit freezers in 2011.
Plus: Is pizza highbrow or lowbrow? Massachusetts-made foods. Where’s the South Shore? The pizza nobody asked for. A serving-size debate over math that should not have taken so long. And several failed attempts at not interrupting.
In the closing segment: Since this pizza isn’t from Cape Cod, Max builds a game to make up for that. Real Cape Cod village or imposter? Will Darren know? Will you?
Shore Thing? Max says Brockton is on the South Shore. Darren questions that because—shocker—it’s not on a shore. Turns out they’re both right, which only makes it more confusing. If you ask the map nerds, the “South Shore” stretches from Boston to the edge of Cape Cod. The state’s own coastal agency runs its South Shore region from Hingham to Plymouth, and a regional planning group’s South Shore Coalition counts thirteen towns, a few of them inland—but neither includes Brockton. It’s the looser, everyday definitions that stretch further inland to towns that don’t touch the water. So is Brockton South Shore? Sure, if you like your beaches made of asphalt.
Serving Suggestion. Max and Darren spent way too much time figuring out whether a pizza box was ordering them to slice the pie into quarters or eighths. Enter the FDA, who set a “reference amount customarily consumed” (RACC) for every food category—which for pizza is set at 140 grams. The label’s official “serving size” has to be whatever fraction of the pie gets closest to that number. On this box, that turned out to be a quarter. On a larger pie, it might be a fifth or sixth. So no, the box isn’t trying to trick you; it’s bureaucratic math trying to convince you that a single frozen pizza feeds a family of four.
The Capeside Down. The namesake (but not the origin) of this week’s pizza is Massachusetts’ giant flexed arm reaching out into the Atlantic—a legendary vacation spot south of Boston (and, by most definitions, not the South Shore). Locals split Cape Cod into four regions: Upper, Mid, Lower, and Outer. So why is the “Upper Cape” the part nearest the mainland, while the “Lower Cape” sits farther out and literally higher up on a standard map? (At least the Outer Cape does end way out in Provincetown.) The favorite local excuse is nautical: going “down Cape” meant heading east where west longitude numbers drop, and sailors were running downwind with the prevailing westerlies. Is that certain? No, it’s folk wisdom, and as one commenter joked, maybe the locals just made it up to keep tourists confused.
Stretching the Truth. Max’s fake village of Dennisville claimed to have the first saltwater taffy shop, and Max assumed taffy was exclusively a Cape Cod thing. Darren guessed it was actually an Atlantic City, New Jersey invention—and he was right. Legend has it that back in the early 1880s, a freakishly high tide flooded candy vendor David Bradley’s boardwalk stand. When a kid walked up asking for candy, Bradley sarcastically offered her some “saltwater taffy.” By 1886, a guy named Joseph Fralinger started boxing the stuff as a souvenir. The plot twist? Zero seawater is actually in the recipe. The Cape sells thousands of pounds of it every summer, but make no mistake: it’s a Jersey import.
Have serving sizes ever confused you? Or do you ignore them entirely?
And most importantly, what candy should go on our Tombstone pizza?
Hit us up on the Let's Chill page and let us know!
Your support means the world to us and keeps our freezer stocked. Every tip and donation helps us discover more frozen finds, cover production costs and improvements, and continue bringing you weekly episodes. Thank you for being part of Froze Nation!
And if you like us, RATE US WHERE YOU LISTEN—and TELL YOUR FRIENDS!
Fro yo' later!
The story: Cape Cod Cafe opened in 1939 in a former funeral home (ghost stories included) on the road to the Cape. In 1947, a newly returned WWII veteran named E. James “Papa” Jamoulis bought it and added pizza to the menu. Three generations later, the family still runs it and claims to have invented bar pizza. The frozen pies hit freezers in 2011.
Plus: Is pizza highbrow or lowbrow? Massachusetts-made foods. Where’s the South Shore? The pizza nobody asked for. A serving-size debate over math that should not have taken so long. And several failed attempts at not interrupting.
In the closing segment: Since this pizza isn’t from Cape Cod, Max builds a game to make up for that. Real Cape Cod village or imposter? Will Darren know? Will you?
WATCH THIS EPISODE
FROST BITES
Shore Thing? Max says Brockton is on the South Shore. Darren questions that because—shocker—it’s not on a shore. Turns out they’re both right, which only makes it more confusing. If you ask the map nerds, the “South Shore” stretches from Boston to the edge of Cape Cod. The state’s own coastal agency runs its South Shore region from Hingham to Plymouth, and a regional planning group’s South Shore Coalition counts thirteen towns, a few of them inland—but neither includes Brockton. It’s the looser, everyday definitions that stretch further inland to towns that don’t touch the water. So is Brockton South Shore? Sure, if you like your beaches made of asphalt.Serving Suggestion. Max and Darren spent way too much time figuring out whether a pizza box was ordering them to slice the pie into quarters or eighths. Enter the FDA, who set a “reference amount customarily consumed” (RACC) for every food category—which for pizza is set at 140 grams. The label’s official “serving size” has to be whatever fraction of the pie gets closest to that number. On this box, that turned out to be a quarter. On a larger pie, it might be a fifth or sixth. So no, the box isn’t trying to trick you; it’s bureaucratic math trying to convince you that a single frozen pizza feeds a family of four.
The Capeside Down. The namesake (but not the origin) of this week’s pizza is Massachusetts’ giant flexed arm reaching out into the Atlantic—a legendary vacation spot south of Boston (and, by most definitions, not the South Shore). Locals split Cape Cod into four regions: Upper, Mid, Lower, and Outer. So why is the “Upper Cape” the part nearest the mainland, while the “Lower Cape” sits farther out and literally higher up on a standard map? (At least the Outer Cape does end way out in Provincetown.) The favorite local excuse is nautical: going “down Cape” meant heading east where west longitude numbers drop, and sailors were running downwind with the prevailing westerlies. Is that certain? No, it’s folk wisdom, and as one commenter joked, maybe the locals just made it up to keep tourists confused.
Stretching the Truth. Max’s fake village of Dennisville claimed to have the first saltwater taffy shop, and Max assumed taffy was exclusively a Cape Cod thing. Darren guessed it was actually an Atlantic City, New Jersey invention—and he was right. Legend has it that back in the early 1880s, a freakishly high tide flooded candy vendor David Bradley’s boardwalk stand. When a kid walked up asking for candy, Bradley sarcastically offered her some “saltwater taffy.” By 1886, a guy named Joseph Fralinger started boxing the stuff as a souvenir. The plot twist? Zero seawater is actually in the recipe. The Cape sells thousands of pounds of it every summer, but make no mistake: it’s a Jersey import.
YOUR COLD CUTS
Have you ever grilled a frozen pizza?Have serving sizes ever confused you? Or do you ignore them entirely?
And most importantly, what candy should go on our Tombstone pizza?
Hit us up on the Let's Chill page and let us know!
ENJOYING THE POD?
BUY US A COLD ONEYour support means the world to us and keeps our freezer stocked. Every tip and donation helps us discover more frozen finds, cover production costs and improvements, and continue bringing you weekly episodes. Thank you for being part of Froze Nation!
And if you like us, RATE US WHERE YOU LISTEN—and TELL YOUR FRIENDS!
Fro yo' later!

