Posts

Showing posts from October, 2026

The Graveyard Shift: Tombstone Pizza with Shaun (Ep 90)

Image
Happy Halloween, Froze Fam, and welcome to the graveyard shift! It’s the end of Pizza Month, and we dressed for the occasion. This week, the Official Pizza of Halloween: Tombstone . The story: Tombstone is named for a Wisconsin bar, which is named for the cemetery across the street. The Simek brothers were running that bar when one of them (Joe, who went by Pep) twisted a little too hard, broke his leg, and got stuck in the kitchen with nothing to do but play with pizza dough. In 1962 they started selling pies, and by 2010 Nestlé owned them. The chocolate people. What goes around comes around. Plus: Candles on the late shift. French freezers and French fries. Ketchup comes in colors. Let’s Twist Again …and again…and again. Getting pizza off the rack and Dunkin abroad. Popcorn balls, chocolate chips, and X Games. Population of Froze Town: still three. In the closing segment: You made suggestions, we made decisions, and nobody’s stomach was consulted. Yup, candy on our pizzas. Trick or t...

Four Heads Are Better Than One: Cauliflower Crust Pizzas (Ep 89)

Image
It’s week three of Pizza Month, and the plan was simple: everybody eats the same cauliflower crust pizza. Then supply and demand got involved. Between empty freezer cases and a last-minute “mayoral decision,” the Bros end up with four pizzas from three brands. This week: a cauliflower crust contest with Shaun and our gluten-free correspondent, Kristen. The story: According to CAULIPOWER itself, it’s the number one cauliflower crust pizza and the number one gluten-free pizza in the U.S. Open Nature is Albertsons’ brand of “clean, minimally processed” foods, with no artificial colors, flavors, sweeteners, or preservatives. Milton’s calls its mission “better-for-you food,” and also makes crackers, breads, and snacks. Plus: Who was the Red Baron? Fried chicken ice cream. A tribute to Mama Celeste. Trader Joe’s fires back. Is Big Air Fryer listening? In the closing segment: Since CAULIPOWER sounds like a superpower, Darren builds a would-you-rather game around the real things—like super ...

Grill, Interrupted: Cape Cod Cafe Cheese Pizza (Ep 88)

Image
Pizza Month rolls on, and the Bros hit the road to Cape Cod. Except they don’t, because Cape Cod Cafe isn’t on Cape Cod. It’s in Brockton, Massachusetts, where a roadside stop turned a 10-inch pan into a South Shore tradition. This week: Cape Cod Cafe Cheese Pizza . The story: Cape Cod Cafe opened in 1939 in a former funeral home (ghost stories included) on the road to the Cape. In 1947, a newly returned WWII veteran named E. James “Papa” Jamoulis bought it and added pizza to the menu. Three generations later, the family still runs it and claims to have invented bar pizza. The frozen pies hit freezers in 2011. Plus: Is pizza highbrow or lowbrow? Massachusetts-made foods. Where’s the South Shore? The pizza nobody asked for . A serving-size debate over math that should not have taken so long. And several failed attempts at not interrupting. In the closing segment: Since this pizza isn’t from Cape Cod, Max builds a game to make up for that. Real Cape Cod village or imposter? Will Darren k...

Grandma, What Big Slices You Have! Di Fara Classic Grandma Pizza (Ep 87)

Image
Happy Pizza Month, Froze Fam! The Bros kick off four pies in a row with a Brooklyn legend that only came to the freezer aisle a year ago. Di Fara Classic Hand-Stretched & Pan-Baked Grandma Pizza . The story: Dom DeMarco opened a Brooklyn pizzeria in 1965 with a partner named Farina. They mashed DeMarco and Farina together, and a name was born. In 1978, DeMarco bought out Farina, and the family has run the place ever since. Plus: The Last Farewell . A solo visit to Stew’s. Key lime pie, and garnishes vs. toppings. McFlurry hacks and a hash brown ice cream sandwich. Protein in the Times . Seed oils, fior di latte , and too many fonts. Triangles, rectangles, and slices in a serving. In the closing segment: The Ice Cold Draft is back. The holidays are coming, and each Bro drafts a team of grandmothers, real and fictional, to host the gathering of their dreams. A queen, a mob matriarch, a grandma who sleeps through the party, and a very well-stocked bar are all involved. WATCH THIS EPIS...